Vjournal standard

8887825 ●

To give a bit more context on this proposal: the vJournal and vTodo parts of the iCalendar standard can be used by apps like jtx Board https://jtx.techbee.at/sync-with-davx5 to provide a fully integrated journal, notes and todo app backed by the CalDAV server.

Reply URL

3

4029155 ●

I too would be highly pleased if this could be used.

At the moment it throws back some 403:Forbidden code.

Is there any plan to implement this?

Reply URL

4

8374393 ●

Same here. I want to condense my various note apps to JTX Board and have it sync with Mailbox. I uninstalled JTX because I got error 403 kickback.

@mailbox, please add support for vjournal so we have a wider selection of clients we can sync to your servers with!

Reply URL

4

6034307 ●

Would also like to see an implementation of vJournal, I'd love to use jtx board with mailbox.org.

Reply URL

3

2750471 ●

Same here, I would really appreciate if it was possible to sync notes to mailbox.org using jtx board.

For me it wouldn't be crucial to also have a web frontend to view and edit notes (though it would be nice).

Reply URL

3

6649005 ●

Same here.

Reply URL

6

9516155 ●

I would also welcome this very much! This would also fit your concept of being open to creative and new solutions, such as opentalk.eu - great thing!

Reply URL

4

Ingo@strohmenger-zahntechnik.de ●

+1 from us for jtx board compatibiity with mailbox.org

Reply URL

4

Verwaltung@strohmenger-zahntechnik.de ●

Das wäre klasse wenn JTX board mit mailbox funktionieren.würde

Reply URL

1

5145019 ●

Warte auch schon lange darauf.

Vielleicht gibt es ja eine Möglichkeit.

Reply URL

3

5598781 ●

VJOURAL support would bei really gerat. +1

THX! :)

Reply URL

3

7650206 ●

I think mailbox.org uses OXchange as a backend, so it should probably added there :)

DAVx5 has worked around the 403 error a few months ago, so at least you can use tasks sync of jtx board.

VJOURNAL support would be awesome of course. At least saving stuff should be not too hard. I doesnt need to have a frontend (would be cool though :D).

Reply URL

3

5819366 ●

Vjournal would be great! :)

Reply URL

3

5236732 ●

VJournal support please.

Reply URL

2

3846606 ●

Yes please, for JTX Board

Reply URL

2

4440450 ●

AS a JTX Board user: yes, please support Vjournal

Reply URL

1

7101355 ●

Yes please implement VJournal, would be awesome!

Reply URL

1

2816690 ●

I would also love VJournal support, please

Reply URL

1

9116821 ●

Yes, please!!

Reply URL

1

johnny ●

Ja bitte, muss jezt einen eigenen server dafür aufrichten mweh

Reply URL

1

jgl ●

Another one requesting support for VJournal please!

Reply URL

1

adrianh ●

Bin auch sehr dafür! Hab gleich mal nachgeschaut, wo VJOURNAL implementiert ist, gibt schließlich viele Server implementierungen, die iTIP vollständig implementieren. Ich kann nur nicht beurteilen ob diese sich ohne weiteres in OXchange integrieren lassen. Selbst wenn nicht, wäre ein zusätzlicher CalDAV Service möglich, z.B. auf Basis von Cyrusmap, als experimentelles Opt-In ohne Support. Ansonsten brauch es einen Feature Request an Open-Xchange...

Gibt es hier denn irgendeinen Fortschritt seitens Mailbox.org?

Reply URL

2

adrianh ●

Hi, sorry for the German post, here is a translation:

Am also very much in favor! Have immediately looked up where VJOURNAL is implemented, there are finally many server implementations that fully implement iTIP. I just can't judge if these can be integrated into OXchange without further ado. Even if not, an additional CalDAV service would be possible, e.g. based on Cyrusmap, as an experimental opt-in without support. Otherwise it needs a feature request to Open-Xchange...

Is there any progress on the part of Mailbox.org?

URL

3

ZenDrake ●

A broad support for the open DAV-based standards would be great. Would love to hear something from Mailbox on this matter.

Reply URL

3

7169558 ●

Peer is too busy drinking champagne and counting money from EU digital sovereignty initiatives to make any improvements to the email service. He says in another thread he's disappointed with OX but will drink wine with them at conferences. Two years and no dark mode, doesn't keep up with DAV standards. Such a joke webmail provider. Just sleeping on their previous laurels.

Reply URL

1

adrianh ●

I agree that drinking champagne can lead to resentments if you are a paying customer with a specific problem. I just asked them in a support ticket if they opened a ticket for a feature request to OX or if they have any roadmap for our request. I suspect it is not on their agenda or low priority or unfeasible right now. Who knows?

Neither VJOURNAL nor VTODO are supported in OX's iTIP implementation, however somehow is functional in mailbox.org. Maybe they did not find a good strategy to "do it the right way", yet. Who knows? As it is, community work could be better. Still, mailbox.org is a decent provider for me, they support open standards as opposed to Protonmail, Tutanova and alike.

I suggest if you want an answer from mailbox.org, send a support ticket, I will let you know when I receive a reply on mine.

P.S. Check the Themes in Basic Settings, there you have Theme called "Mailbox Dark". That might work as Dark Mode :)

URL

5

Peer Heinlein [mailbox.org] ●

I do not shy away from discussion and am always available to our users here and in other forums to provide answers and explanations.

As long as it involves a factual, respectful interaction that is solution-oriented and focused on the matter at hand.

I will not engage in malicious, polemical, insinuating, or disrespectful discussions, and I will not be provoked.

In the case of false claims, however, I must clarify them.

*) At no point have I or any of my companies received money from the EU digital sovereignty funds. This is totally wrong and a lie. I have funded OpenTalk entirely privately with my own money so far.

*) The development of OpenTalk (through a separate company) has no impact on and is not related to mailbox.org.

*) I don't even like champagne that much.

You have no idea what is really going on and happening. I won't respond in-depth to polemical posts.Sorry, can't / don't want to help here.

URL

4

5145019 ●

I'm an engineer and I want to go back to our basic request.
Which is to check if there is a way to implement jtx data exchange (vjournal) and not bother Peer.
@Peer is there a solution planned within 1 year?

URL

2

5819366 ●

I agree on the DAV standards, seems like that Mailbox isn't implementation anything new. Seems like a mesh up of different services and clients. Mailbox need a big UI modification and work on the implementation of new standards. This request has been opened 18 months ago. How long can it take lol.

btw, nothing wrong with making good money and drinking wine lol

URL

3

adrianh ●

@Peer I am with you, just trying to find some common ground with @7169558, personally I don't think it is important which beverages you prefer. I like coffee :). Personally I do not want to judge how much Mailbox implements by themselves. But with all respect, I would like to know where we are regarding VJOURNAL

Back to topic: Is there a plan to bring VJOURNAL at some point? Is it possible to provide the necessary backend components (experimentally, beta-testing, opt-in?), just satisfy everyone here who would like to use jtx Board? I bet that many people in this topic would be just happy with that. If this is not feasible, please let us know anyways.

URL

1

Cardoso ●

Same wishes here

URL

4

Z ●

Any update on VJournal standard? I understand you find it necessary to respond to the offensive comment, yet can you also

"be always available to our users here and in other forums to provide answers and explanations."?

Except for the clarification, it seems you made no answer in 2 years for a quite legitimate proposal.

URL

3

TOSE mailbox ●

Would be great to get a reply. As a jtx board user this would make me very happy!

Should we start another thread since this one has gotten rather polemic a few posts above this one?

Reply URL

1

gamebird92 ●

As a new user I followed your guides on how to set up jtx board to access tasks. At first I was wondering why journal and notes does not get synced until I dived a little bit deeper and gained some more know-how.

Would be a very cool feature to add vjournal to also support journal and notes :)

So as some people before me I wanted to ask what's the current status on this feature. Didn't find an official answer if it will be supported or not, or if it is even considered about thinking to be integrated.

Can you please share your current opinion on this topic?

Reply URL

1

3191960 ●

Another vote to support JtxBoard. I know, that most people feel bad about the state of task management, even in the year of 2025. It seems, that with the right backend implementation JtxBoard could be a solution.

Reply URL

1

Raffael Mancini ●

I'm also looking for decent vJournal and vTodo support!

Reply URL

Vjournal standard

Replies (28)